The brain defense: murder in Manhattan and the dawn of neuroscience in America's courtrooms

Book Cover
Average Rating
Publisher:
Varies, see individual formats and editions
Pub. Date:
2017.
Language:
English
Description
Called "the best kind of nonfiction" by Michael Connelly, this riveting new book combines true crime, brain science, and courtroom drama. In 1991, the police were called to East 72nd St. in Manhattan, where a woman's body had fallen from a twelfth-story window. The woman's husband, Herbert Weinstein, soon confessed to having hit and strangled his wife after an argument, then dropping her body out of their apartment window to make it look like a suicide. The 65-year-old Weinstein, a quiet, unassuming retired advertising executive, had no criminal record, no history of violent behavior--not even a short temper. How, then, to explain this horrific act? Journalist Kevin Davis uses the perplexing story of the Weinstein murder to present a riveting, deeply researched exploration of the intersection of neuroscience and criminal justice. Shortly after Weinstein was arrested, an MRI revealed a cyst the size of an orange on his brain's frontal lobe, the part of the brain that governs judgment and impulse control. Weinstein's lawyer seized on that discovery, arguing that the cyst had impaired Weinstein's judgment and that he should not be held criminally responsible for the murder. It was the first case in the United States in which a judge allowed a scan showing a defendant's brain activity to be admitted as evidence to support a claim of innocence. The Weinstein case marked the dawn of a new era in America's courtrooms, raising complex and often troubling questions about how we define responsibility and free will, how we view the purpose of punishment, and how strongly we are willing to bring scientific evidence to bear on moral questions. Davis brings to light not only the intricacies of the Weinstein case but also the broader history linking brain injuries and aberrant behavior, from the bizarre stories of Phineas Gage and Charles Whitman, perpetrator of the 1966 Texas Tower massacre, to the role that brain damage may play in violence carried out by football players and troubled veterans of America's twenty-first century wars. The Weinstein case opened the door for a novel defense that continues to transform the legal system: Criminal lawyers are increasingly turning to neuroscience and introducing the effects of brain injuries--whether caused by trauma or by tumors, cancer, or drug or alcohol abuse--and arguing that such damage should be considered in determining guilt or innocence, the death penalty or years behind bars. As he takes stock of the past, present and future of neuroscience in the courts, Davis offers a powerful account of its potential and its hazards. Thought-provoking and brilliantly crafted, The Brain Defense marries a murder mystery complete with colorful characters and courtroom drama with a sophisticated discussion of how our legal system has changed--and must continue to change--as we broaden our understanding of the human mind.
Also in This Series
More Like This
More Details
ISBN:
9781594206337
9780698183353
Reviews from GoodReads
Loading GoodReads Reviews.
Staff View

Grouping Information

Grouped Work ID f95c0960-b84a-5af6-0e4e-85a47b07ce98
Grouping Title brain defense murder in manhattan and the dawn of neuroscience in americas courtrooms
Grouping Author davis kevin
Grouping Category book
Last Grouping Update 2018-09-25 22:58:20PM
Last Indexed 2018-09-26 00:25:53AM

Solr Details

accelerated_reader_interest_level
accelerated_reader_point_value 0
accelerated_reader_reading_level 0
author Davis, Kevin (Kevin A.),
author_display Davis, Kevin
available_at_catalog Bellevue, Bellevue Kids, Edmondson Pike, Edmondson Pike Kids, Green Hills, Green Hills Kids, Main Kids, Main Library
collection_catalog Non-Fiction
detailed_location_catalog Bellevue - Adult Non-Fiction, Edmondson Pike - Adult Non-Fiction, Green Hills - Adult Non-Fiction, Main Library - Adult Non-Fiction
display_description "In 1991, the police were called to East 72nd St. in Manhattan, where a woman's body had fallen from a twelfth-story window. The woman's husband, Herbert Weinstein, soon confessed to having hit and strangled his wife after an argument, then dropping her body out of their apartment window to make it look like a suicide. The 65-year-old Weinstein, a quiet, unassuming retired advertising executive, had no criminal record, no history of violent behavior--not even a short temper. How, then, to explain this horrific act? Journalist Kevin Davis uses the perplexing story of the Weinstein murder to present a riveting, deeply researched exploration of the intersection of neuroscience and criminal justice. Shortly after Weinstein was arrested, an MRI revealed a cyst the size of an orange on his brain's frontal lobe, the part of the brain that governs judgment and impulse control. Weinstein's lawyer seized on that discovery, arguing that the cyst had impaired Weinstein's judgment and that he should not be held criminally responsible for the murder. It was the first case in the United States in which a judge allowed a scan showing a defendant's brain activity to be admitted as evidence to support a claim of innocence. The Weinstein case marked the dawn of a new era in America's courtrooms, raising complex and often troubling questions about how we define responsibility and free will, how we view the purpose of punishment, and how strongly we are willing to bring scientific evidence to bear on moral questions. Davis brings to light not only the intricacies of the Weinstein case but also the broader history linking brain injuries and aberrant behavior, from the bizarre stories of Phineas Gage and Charles Whitman, perpetrator of the 1966 Texas Tower massacre, to the role that brain damage may play in violence carried out by football players and troubled veterans of America's twenty-first century wars. The Weinstein case opened the door for a novel defense that continues to transform the legal system: Criminal lawyers are increasingly turning to neuroscience and introducing the effects of brain injuries--whether caused by trauma or by tumors, cancer, or drug or alcohol abuse--and arguing that such damage should be considered in determining guilt or innocence, the death penalty or years behind bars. As he takes stock of the past, present and future of neuroscience in the courts, Davis offers a powerful account of its potential and its hazards. Thought-provoking and brilliantly crafted, The Brain Defense marries a murder mystery complete with colorful characters and courtroom drama with a sophisticated discussion of how our legal system has changed--and must continue to change--as we broaden our understanding of the human mind"--
format_catalog Book, eBook
format_category_catalog Books, eBook
id f95c0960-b84a-5af6-0e4e-85a47b07ce98
isbn 9780698183353, 9781594206337
item_details ils:CARL0000503115|35192049392552|Bellevue - Adult Non-Fiction|345.73 D2628b|||1|false|false|||||On Shelf||BL||, ils:CARL0000503115|35192049392560|Edmondson Pike - Adult Non-Fiction|345.73 D2628b|||1|false|false|||||On Shelf||EP||, ils:CARL0000503115|35192049392578|Green Hills - Adult Non-Fiction|345.73 D2628b|||1|false|false|||||On Shelf||GH||, ils:CARL0000503115|35192049392586|Main Library - Adult Non-Fiction|345.73 D2628b|||1|false|false|||||On Shelf||MN||, ils:CARL0000503115|QQ00305839|Hillsboro High - Teen Non-Fiction|345.74 Dav|||1|false|false|||||On Shelf||66435||, ils:CARL0000503115|QQ00307762|McGavock High - Teen Non-Fiction|345.74 Dav|||1|false|false|||||On Shelf||6D532||, overdrive:02f09d3c-6e8a-4704-968c-dfb8133aecf0|-1|Online OverDrive Collection|Online OverDrive|eBook|eBook|1|false|true|OverDrive|||Adobe EPUB eBook,Kindle Book,OverDrive Read|Available Online||||
itype_catalog , Book
last_indexed 2018-09-26T05:25:53.964Z
lexile_score -1
literary_form Non Fiction
literary_form_full Non Fiction
local_callnumber_catalog 345.73 D2628b
owning_library_catalog Nashville Public Library
owning_location_catalog Bellevue, Bellevue Kids, Edmondson Pike, Edmondson Pike Kids, Green Hills, Green Hills Kids, Main Kids, Main Library
primary_isbn 9781594206337
publishDate 2017
record_details ils:CARL0000503115|Book|Books||English|Penguin Press,|2017.|326 pages ; 25 cm., overdrive:02f09d3c-6e8a-4704-968c-dfb8133aecf0|eBook|eBook||English|Penguin Publishing Group|2017|
recordtype grouped_work
scoping_details_catalog
Bib IdItem IdGrouped StatusStatusLocally OwnedAvailableHoldableBookableIn Library Use OnlyLibrary OwnedHoldable PTypesBookable PTypesLocal Url
overdrive:02f09d3c-6e8a-4704-968c-dfb8133aecf0 -1 Available Online Available Online false true true false false false
ils:CARL0000503115 35192049392586 On Shelf On Shelf false true true false false true
ils:CARL0000503115 35192049392578 On Shelf On Shelf false true true false false true
ils:CARL0000503115 35192049392560 On Shelf On Shelf false true true false false true
ils:CARL0000503115 35192049392552 On Shelf On Shelf false true true false false true
subject_facet Brain -- Diseases -- Law and legislation -- New York (State), Forensic neurology -- New York (State), Insanity (Law) -- New York (State), Trial and arbitral proceedings, Trials (Murder) -- New York (State) -- New York, Weinstein, Herbert -- Trials, litigation, etc
title_display The brain defense : murder in Manhattan and the dawn of neuroscience in America's courtrooms
title_full The Brain Defense Murder in Manhattan and the Dawn of Neuroscience in America's Courtrooms, The brain defense : murder in Manhattan and the dawn of neuroscience in America's courtrooms / Kevin Davis
title_short The brain defense :
title_sub murder in Manhattan and the dawn of neuroscience in America's courtrooms
topic_facet Brain, Diseases, Forensic neurology, Insanity (Law), Law, Law and legislation, Nonfiction, Politics, Psychology, Trials (Murder), Trials, litigation, etc, Weinstein, Herbert